Equities & sectorsVoya Investment Management
3 in 3: Where Can You Still Find Opportunity in Defensives?
United StatesElectrification & the gridTariffs & trade policy
Our summary
The defensive re-rating has largely run its course in health care and consumer staples, while utilities retain relative opportunity if they execute on power demand and protect customer affordability.
- Health care ETF XLV rose more than 30% over six months, moving from an 18% discount to the S&P 500 to a 9% premium, which leaves the sector less attractive after its repricing.
- Consumer staples have also undergone a sharp re-rating in recent months, reducing their appeal compared with their earlier valuation.
- Utilities remain broadly flat and are still trading at a discount to the wider equity market, with improving fundamentals linked to data-center electricity demand.
- Takeaways from the utility industry's EEI conference were that bankable data-center loads matter more than headline pipeline figures, with transmission, generation, permitting, and financing still limiting growth.
- Utility winners will need to connect new loads, fund construction, and show that data centers can operate without destabilizing household bills; management teams described the expected political shift as an evolution, while long-term power contracts continue to be signed.
- Some consumer companies and automakers reported margin gains after courts invalidated major import tariffs, with refunds adding almost six percentage points to gross margins in one case and leaving other margins flat or lower after adjustment.
Takeaway: Utilities offer the clearest remaining defensive opportunity, subject to execution and affordability risks, while investors should reassess consumer earnings in 2027 when tariff refunds disappear and costs remain high.
Published by Voya Investment Management. Summary by HF Best Ideas.