All research
Investing process & styleThornburg Investment Management

When the Machines Sell: Amplified Market Fragility and Why It Could Favor the Patient, Unlevered Investor

United StatesMarket concentration

Our summary

Modern market structure can turn a political repricing into a self-reinforcing equity selloff, creating buying opportunities for patient investors without leverage.

  • On November 5, 2026, the Nasdaq 100 fell 6.4%, the S&P 500 lost 4.4%, the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index dropped more than 12%, and $3.7 trillion of US market value disappeared in one session.
  • Morgan Stanley estimated that retail investors sold about $3 billion in the first hours of trading, a 5.7-standard-deviation event, after Citadel Securities had recorded roughly $33 billion of retail net buying across the previous 22 sessions.
  • The VIX rose from 16.6 to nearly 28, prompting Nomura to estimate $61 billion of sales from volatility-control strategies and Barclays to estimate a 30-percentage-point reduction in their equity exposure.
  • Trend-following CTAs sold about $13 billion of index futures, leveraged ETFs generated roughly $47 billion of rebalancing sales, and options dealers added about $7 billion of selling for each 1% market decline.
  • Concentration increased the damage: 337 S&P 500 stocks rose on October 22 while the index fell 1.2%, and memory, optical-networking, and data-center baskets fell 12% to 15% on November 5.

Takeaway: Unlevered fundamental investors can use forced selling to buy durable businesses when prices fall below assessed intrinsic value, while accepting that the approach does not predict market bottoms.

Published by Thornburg Investment Management. Summary by HF Best Ideas.

More from Thornburg Investment Management

Latest research

Share this summary