Private markets & real assetsManulife Investment Management
Direct lending: finding relative value in a competitive market
Private credit
Our summary
Direct lending manager performance is likely to diverge increasingly through recovery rates as underwriting weaknesses from the competitive cycle surface.
- Banks ceded market share after the global financial crisis, and direct lending grew at about a 14% compound annual rate over the past 10 years, while assets under management more than doubled over the past 5 years.
- Competition encouraged higher leverage, weaker or absent covenants, diluted enforcement rights, PIK features, and liability management exercises, with risks expected to emerge as portfolios age.
- PIK represented about 8% of interest income for BDCs, and investors should distinguish PIK agreed at origination from later payment-in-kind amendments that may signal borrower distress.
- Around 80% of liability management exercises conducted through restructurings have reportedly defaulted again, making exposure to these provisions an important due diligence question.
- Retail capital through non-traded BDCs accounts for about 15% of the market, while software represents roughly 20% of the average direct lender's exposure and may face disruption from artificial intelligence.
Takeaway: Allocators should assess sourcing across sponsored and non-sponsored lending, underwriting standards, covenant and enforcement protections, valuation practices, AI risk resources, concentration limits, and workout capacity because recovery outcomes may drive manager dispersion.
Published by Manulife Investment Management. Summary by HF Best Ideas.